HSBC’s Acquisition of Silicon Valley Bank UK Limited
Deal Overview:
In March 2023, HSBC acquired Silicon Valley Bank UK Limited (SVB UK) for the nominal sum of £1 following the collapse of its US parent company. At the time of acquisition, SVB UK had approximately £5.5 billion in loans and £6.7 billion in deposits. This strategic move enabled HSBC to strengthen its commercial banking capabilities, particularly in the technology and life sciences sectors, by integrating SVB UK's specialised services and client base. The deal also ensured the continuity of banking services and safeguarded depositors without requiring public funds
Company Details: Acquirer - HSBC
Founded: 1865
CEO: Noel Quinn (as of 2023)
Industry: Banking and Financial Services
HSBC is one of the world’s largest banking and financial services organisations. It offers a wide range of services, including retail banking, wealth management, commercial banking, investment banking, and global markets. The bank has a significant international presence, operating in over 60 countries and territories worldwide. HSBC operates across various sectors including corporate banking, personal banking, investment banking, and insurance. It serves both retail customers and corporations, with a focus on providing cross-border financial services and facilitating international trade and investment. HSBC has consistently maintained a strong global footprint and is recognised for its expertise in international banking. It caters to millions of customers globally, with a particular focus on emerging markets and areas of high growth, including Asia.
Company Details: Target - Silicon Valley Bank UK Limited (SVB UK)
Founded: 2012 (as SVB UK, a subsidiary of Silicon Valley Bank)
CEO: Greg W. Becker (CEO of Silicon Valley Bank, the parent company of SVB UK)
Industry: Banking and Financial Services
SVB UK operated as a commercial bank primarily serving technology, life sciences, and healthcare sectors. It provided services including lending, treasury management, and venture capital funding to innovative and high-growth companies. SVB UK offered specialised financial products tailored to startups and fast-growing businesses, including financing solutions for tech companies. Its clientele consisted largely of high-risk but high-potential tech firms that often had significant funding needs for growth and development. SVB UK’s operations were tightly integrated with the Silicon Valley tech ecosystem, hence their customised financial solutions which supported the expansion of tech and innovation-driven businesses.
Points of Contention:
The acquisition of Silicon Valley Bank UK Limited (SVB UK) by HSBC occurred amidst a financial crisis triggered by the collapse of its parent company, Silicon Valley Bank (SVB), in the United States. SVB UK had been operating in the UK since 2012 and was deeply integrated with its US parent, which provided essential infrastructure, including payment systems. However, SVB’s portfolio of long-dated bonds suffered significant losses as interest rates rose in the US, and the bank was unable to hedge these risks. This vulnerability was compounded by rapid depositor withdrawals, exacerbated by social media speculation, leading to SVB’s collapse in the US by 10 March 2023. SVB UK, while able to meet withdrawal demands on 10 March, faced a liquidity crisis, and its reliance on the US parent meant it could not function independently. This prompted the Bank of England, in coordination with US authorities, to prepare for SVB UK’s potential insolvency.
At first, the Bank of England leaned toward placing SVB UK into a Bank Insolvency Procedure (BIP), as no buyer was immediately available. However, after the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) in the US closed SVB, interest from potential buyers emerged. Among these, HSBC proved to be the only credible bidder, offering the liquidity and financial stability required to ensure the continuity of banking services. HSBC’s bid was particularly favourable as it did not require public funds or government guarantees, aligning with the Bank of England’s objective to minimise risks to taxpayers and public finances. HSBC’s substantial capital resources allowed it to provide the liquidity necessary to stabilise SVB UK. Given the urgency of the situation, the Bank of England, in consultation with other regulators like the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), the Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA), and HM Treasury (HMT), decided to proceed with the acquisition. The resolution process was initiated on 13 March 2023, with the transfer of SVB UK’s shares to HSBC for a nominal £1.
Precedents Set:
The acquisition has set significant legal and regulatory precedents, particularly in the context of the UK’s financial resolution framework. A crucial decision by the Bank of England was its application of special resolution powers to ensure the continuity of banking services, safeguard depositors, and maintain public confidence in the financial system. This decision underscored the flexibility of the UK’s resolution regime and the need for adjustments to existing legislation to address the unique circumstances of the deal.
A key legal issue in this acquisition was the matter of ‘ring-fencing’, a regulatory measure introduced after the 2008 financial crisis to separate retail banking from riskier investment activities. This was intended to protect depositors from the risks associated with more speculative banking activities. However, SVB UK’s operations spanned both retail and non-retail banking, creating a legal challenge for its acquisition by HSBC, which is a ring-fenced bank. To resolve this, the UK government used its powers to extend the ring-fencing carve-out indefinitely, allowing HSBC to acquire SVB UK while maintaining protections for retail banking activities. This exemption, although unusual, was deemed necessary to make the acquisition commercially viable and ensure stability in the banking sector. Safeguards were also put in place through the section 75 order, preventing SVB UK from holding core deposits above the allowed threshold and from expanding its business. While this move diverged from the usual application of ring-fencing rules, it was justified due to the exceptional circumstances of the deal and the need to preserve financial stability.
Another key legal consideration was the valuation of SVB UK’s assets and liabilities. The Bank of England conducted a provisional valuation of SVB UK during the resolution weekend in March 2023, due to the urgency of the situation. This provisional assessment showed that the write-down of SVB UK’s capital was necessary to meet regulatory requirements. Importantly, both this and the independent valuation later confirmed that SVB UK’s creditors would not be worse off than in an insolvency, reinforcing the Special Resolution Regime’s (SRR) principle that creditors should not suffer more harm in a resolution scenario than in bankruptcy. The FSCS’s protection of depositors was also confirmed, ensuring they would recover 100% of their claims. This process solidified the precedent that the UK’s resolution framework can effectively protect depositors and creditors without requiring additional public intervention, setting a benchmark for future financial crises.
The broader implications of this acquisition highlight the importance of a flexible legal system in times of financial crisis. The Bank of England’s ability to adapt regulations, such as extending the ring-fencing carve-out, was crucial in ensuring HSBC’s successful acquisition of SVB UK.
The Future:
The UK's existing laws governing banking acquisitions and resolutions are evolving to address emerging challenges. The swift resolution of the Silicon Valley Bank UK (SVB UK) acquisition by HSBC in March 2023 highlighted the effectiveness of current frameworks in protecting depositors and maintaining financial stability. However, the rapid pace of financial markets and the unique nature of such acquisitions have underscored the need for continuous refinement of these laws. The UK government has recognised this necessity and is actively pursuing legislative enhancements. The proposed Bank Resolution (Recapitalisation) Bill aims to strengthen the UK's bank resolution regime, particularly concerning smaller banks. This bill seeks to empower the Bank of England to utilise funds from the banking sector to cover certain costs associated with resolving a failing bank and facilitating its sale.
Additionally, the Financial Services and Markets Bill is under consideration to create a more competitive financial services sector post-Brexit, while preserving high regulatory standards. These legislative initiatives reflect a proactive approach to adapting the UK's financial regulatory framework to the evolving landscape. By implementing these changes, the UK aims to enhance the resilience of its financial system, ensuring that it remains robust and responsive to future challenges.
References:
Bank of England (2024). Report under section 79A of the Banking Act 2009 on the transfer of Silicon Valley Bank UK to HSBC UK. [online] Bankofengland.co.uk. Available at: https://www.bankofengland.co.uk/paper/2024/report-under-section-79a-of-the-banking-act-2009-on-the-transfer-of-svb-uk-to-hsbc-uk.
Gobler, E. (2024). What Happened to Silicon Valley Bank? [online] Investopedia. Available at: https://www.investopedia.com/what-happened-to-silicon-valley-bank-7368676.
Hogan Lovells (2024). UK: King’s Speech 2024: Key takeaways for financial services. [online] www.hoganlovells.com. Available at: https://www.hoganlovells.com/en/publications/uk-kings-speech-2024-key-takeaways-for-financial-services [Accessed 1 Jan. 2025].
HSBC buys Silicon Valley Bank’s UK unit for £1 in rescue deal. (2023). Financial Times. [online] 13 Mar. Available at: https://www.ft.com/content/216b193d-62b3-4e5e-8f67-e8eb3d96ebf1.
Makortoff, K. (2023). HSBC to buy Silicon Valley Bank UK for £1 in government rescue deal. The Guardian. [online] 13 Mar. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/business/2023/mar/13/hsbc-buy-silicon-valley-banks-uk-tech-startups.
Ryan, A. (2023). Legal Business. [online] Legal Business. Available at: https://www.legalbusiness.co.uk/blogs/crisis-averted-city-banking-and-corporate-partners-react-as-hsbc-acquires-svb-uk/ [Accessed 1 Jan. 2025].
Turner, J. (2023). Why did Silicon Valley Bank fail? [online] Economics Observatory. Available at: https://www.economicsobservatory.com/why-did-silicon-valley-bank-fail.
UK Finance. (n.d.). Financial Services and Markets Bill. [online] Available at: https://www.ukfinance.org.uk/financial-services-and-markets-bill.
www.youtube.com. (n.d.). How Silicon Valley Bank Collapsed in 36 Hours | What Went Wrong | WSJ. [online] Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QACGoKb48_0.